Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Cherry picking

This is not a fruit related post.

For the past couple of weeks our visitors have come home with a USA today, so I have been catching verbal crossword clues and reading USAT's articles and one in particular intrigued me - an editorial on best practices that America could adopt by looking at the way other countries tackle problems that the US has.  The article can be found by google-ing lessons america can learn from other countries (I don't want to get sued by USA today for copyright infringement as this is such a new article)  USAT did one article US and World Report News did the other.  Both articles were fascinating eg Finland values teachers more highly, subsidizes their education trains them better before they even step into the classroom.  Germany has apprenticeship schemes, which teach basic skills things like plumbing, carpentry, brick laying etc and Canada didn't have a housing crisis because it didn't allow the practices that caused the one in the US to flourish.  That's the basics of the article and the US WRN is more of the same but the thing that floored me was the comments section.

There is something about anonymous online posting that brings out the worst in people and in those fifteen pages of mostly nasty comment you could literally put a label on the poster.  The TPs - no one does it better than us, our country is in a mess because of weak liberal policies. The Republicans - Ah but Finland are communist/socialists (two completely different ideologies)  Canada pah! and if you challenge me I'm right and you're wrong and why don't you move to Finland/Germany/Canada if you like their ideas so much.  Ds  We need to look for new ideas but who is going to pay for them - we're not.  And last but not least the Normals (2%?) who advocated the ideas and suggested that adapting them to fit the US was the way to go - and raising taxes to pay for them.

Each side cherry picked facts that supported their position.  Lets face it the US has problems and they need to be solved and looking outward rather than looking inward might help and for starters how about cutting government salaries and getting back in touch with the people.  Here is a classic example from the ap news wires

But Republican Boehner said that tax increases are a nonstarter: "The American people will not accept — and the House cannot pass — a bill that raises taxes on job creators."  

Boner (hey that's how its spelt) says he is speaking for the American people.  Maybe he should ask the American people what they want.  Some will of course not want their taxes raised.  Some will quote the trickle down that tax cuts for the rich brings for the rest of us - which isn't really trickling anywhere except into the rich man's pocket.  Some - like me - will ask how the Clinton administration left the federal government coffers overflowing with cash.  He raised taxes - as this 1993 Washington Post article shows.  Some will also ask why if it worked then it wouldn't work now.  Say what you like about Clinton but he left office with the highest approval rating of any serving President since WWII (most Presidents have some kind of skeleton in their closet he had a whole graveyard full. One thing Clinton wasn't was dull)

Comments welcome here, by e-mail or at the shop but don't hide behind anonymous screen names.  I don't choose my friends by which party they support. 

Why Netflix? Why?

If you watch Jon Stewart this is a 'meet me at camera three' moment.  If you don't we'll  just call it an open letter.

Netflix, you were a company I respected.  I liked your business model, it was simple, streamlined and straightforward.  We made a list and BluRay movies appeared in the post, we sent them back in the could've been designed by apple return envelope.  Life was good - then life got better - you added instant streaming. All for $11 dollars a month.  Yesterday under the misleading banner of more choice (ie more profits) you split the two services. Now if we want both movies in the mail and streaming it will cost us just under $20 (starting in September) 

Hubby thinks this is a prelude to ditching your original model (the one that made you into a household name and a verb) and going to streaming only.  When I asked why that was a bad idea he started spouting words and numbers like 1080p and impossible and not enough bandwidth so I stopped him before he blew up.  In layman's terms you can't stream BluRays because there isn't enough bandwidth (think how annoying it is when you try and watch a you tube clip (buffering, buffering) imagine that while trying to watch a movie)

So Netflix here's the bottom line, in a time when money is tight you jack up the price for both services.  Genius.  As of today we no longer stream and I kind of hate you a little right now.  

Friday, June 17, 2011

Is shunning the sun good for you?

In the wake of the new FDA  guidelines for sunscreen that came out this week  I decided to look at the pros and cons of sun exposure. And to do that I took one of the most memorable campaigns I could think of.

In Australia in the early eighties the government launched the Slip-Slop-Slap campaign to ingrain the dangers of skin cancer into their outdoorsy population.  Slip on a shirt, Slop on suncreen and Slap on a hat.  It worked so well that in recent years they've added Seek shade and Slide on the sunnies (sunglasses) but when I read the results of the studies I was surprised to find that although the basic forms of skin cancer - basal cell and squamous carcenomas  - decreased the incidence of melanoma increased.  So did cases of Osteoporosis in adults.And in a few rare cases children who had been religiously protected from the sun since birth by their careful parents had developed rickets (see link at the base of this post).

Many scientists believe that a lack of vitamin D - known as the sunshine vitamin because we naturally produce it as a result of sun exposure is the answer.  So how much exposure are we talking about.  Opinions vary but to avoid being one of the 30 - 70 % of patients who are D deficient just 10-15 minutes of unprotected exposure is enough for the body to produce its daily quota of Vitamin D.  For those who believe that no sun is the best way to go there are Vitamin D supplements (which I take in the winter when the winter sun is too weak to stimulate much production.)

Moderation would appear to be the key.

Please note that we are having a debate here - I'm not issuing medical advice because I'm not a Doctor, or a scientist but I noticed that all the media coverage focused on the sun giving you skin cancer and the other information got lost in the media shuffle. 



http://www.bmj.com/content/318/7175/39.extract - NB the full article on rickets is subscription only but the extract gives the basic information.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Help! how do I turn down the positive reinforcement?

Positive reinforcement, according to my mini 3rd edition OED -

Positive meaning showing the presence rather than the absence of particular features

and

Reinforcement meaning the action of making stronger

When I did a quick internet search the first thing that came up was animal behaviour, reward your doggy with a treat.  Of course the major use of positive reinforcement is in parenting.  But while society tells us that this is a good method to train dogs and kids how much is too much and should we be carrying this 'good job!" attitude into adulthood?

Concepts like discipline and constructive criticism are so twenty years ago.  I'm pretty sure that if I went back to school now, I could coast, and probably pass the subjects I failed because no one wants to be seen to be failing our kids.  Problem is school may be social hell but the real world won't cosset you.  If you don't turn in those monthly figures your boss requested he won't give you a lolly pop and say well done for trying, he will kick your ass - metaphorically speaking.  He won't give you a hug if you muff that presentation to the Japanese conglomerate, he will fire your ass.  If you fail at something, you either won't bother with it again or it'll spur you on to try harder.  I'll give you an example I hated Latin - with a passion and I had the chance to drop it but my teacher told me in front of the rest of the class that I would be better off dropping the subject as I didn't have an aptitude for languages.  He later told me that it was a calculated criticism on his part because he expected me to rise to the challenge, as the two languages I was studying at the time held their roots in Latin. 

Saying 'I can't fail' is the same as saying 'the earth is flat' nothing is too big or too small to fail.  But failure is also a tool, you can use your mistakes or that wrong answer to the chemistry question to look at another solution.  Think of your first swimming lesson where you sucked in half the pool, or the first time you tried to ride a bicycle.  We're human we make mistakes and its OK to compliment someone on a job well done.  But it you do it every thirty seconds it has no meaning.


http://www.dogmanners.com/posreinforce.html
http://www.specialconnections.ku.edu/cgi-bin/cgiwrap/specconn/main.php?cat=behavior&section=main&subsection=classroom/positive

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

About subtle - or not so sublte cultural differences

This has been bugging me for weeks so now I'm throwing it out there.  If you are a recent arrival in another country or even if you've been living in a foreign country for years are there things that you just expect to obtain without use of the internet, local foods that you grew up with, the school system, the rubbish collection system, transport, sales tax, healthcare, things that shouldn't broadside you but do?

In my case I've been trying to drink less soda.  Easy, I thought, I can still have fizzy drinks, I'll just buy a sodastream and drink fizzy squash all summer. Buying the sodastream wasn't a problem.  Squash however was.  The squash I am referring too isn't the sport, or the vegetable it is a  fruity concentrate (usually orange) that you dilute with water to make a drink.

It's a staple in England, in fact we never had coke or pepsi in the house that's why I still have teeth.

None of the supermarkets had it, they had plenty of fruit juice, crystal light (which sounded like a plan until I read the ingredients) pre-mixed drinks, and of course the dreaded coke aisle but while fruit juice kind of works, it's not squash.  So off  I went to Whole Foods (or whole paycheck as my friends call it) juices galore but no squash.  Luckily for me we have the London Market and the Old Dutch Store in Utah, both of whom sell squash in various flavours but because it is imported it is not cheap.


So here's what I want to know.  Is this a Utah thing or a whole of America thing.

5/16 Several suggestions from fb and e-mail for Mio - a liquid water enhancer (Is there a solid water enhancer?)  I checked it out and having read the back and not even found the strawberry flavouring in the strawberry watermelon variety five ingredients in I think I'll pass.  Thanks for the suggestions though - oh and apparently in the US they don't call it squash they call it cordial.  I stand corrected.

7/13 Torino make syrups which you can use to flavour Italian sodas, my current favourite is the sugar free vanilla.  A tiny amount goes a long way.

Friday, May 6, 2011

Why did I buy that? Pt 1

Infomercials.  Most of the time I'm immune but once in a while, I can't help looking at a product and thinking - that's a really cool idea - a simple idea - that deals with a problem that I want to solve.  The problem - identity theft. The solution? a wallet made of aluminium. The aluma wallet.  For the last year I've carried around a bulky German designed wallet that protects my cards but is a giant hassle because is it designed for European cards my driver's license is just a little too snug to slide out - every time I travel. So when the Aluma wallet finally appeared locally I bought one.

May 6 : This morning I loaded everything from my old wallet into my spanking new electric blue wallet and straight away there's a problem.  I can't get it all in. The wallet has seven plastic compartments - this means I can carry six cards plus a small amount of cash and no business cards - which might be a good thing.  There are also two weak points - the hinge and the clip that opens and shuts.  Both are made from cheapie plastic.  On the plus side it fits in my jeans' pocket which das deutsche never did.  Will take it shopping and see how it fares.

May 7 : Has already started to scratch, very useful at airport security - no problem pulling out my driver's license.  It is hefty though and if you threw it at someone it would hurt.

May 18 : Pleasantly surprised that the wallet survived the trip.  Have had it in my pocket all the time and it hasn't deformed although it is covered in minute scratches.  Have had several people say it looks cool.  It has jammed a couple of times and it is only built for cards and paper money and for now I'll live with that.

April 28th : Lasted less than a year before the opening clip broke only way to open wallet was with a screwdriver. Not sure I'll buy another one.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Polygraph Anyone?

We all tell white lies - I'll give you an example.  At some point today someone you know will ask you how you are and guess what you'll say? 'good thanks' or 'I'm fine' and then you'll move on to the meat of the conversation.  If you said, 'I've got post-nasal drip and a mouth like the bottom of a birdcage' the pleasantries come to a screeching halt and - well it's awkward.  So we lie.  We lie to be polite, to make someone feel better about themselves, but these are harmless fictions.

I'm talking about the official, blatent, in-your-face whoppers.  Lies that take us to war, or damage our economy.  Lies that go on record as statements of fact.  The truth is we have become lazy, we don't research, we don't question, we just believe and worse we trust.  I was brought up to question authority, I never had much time for politics or politicians, they always make promises they can't keep and in political circles the bigger the lie the more people are likely to swallow it.  The big offenders for this are news anchors mainly on the FOX news network - although there are offenders on other networks and of course big oil.  But by far the worst are the people we democratically elected to represent us on a federal and state level.

Republican Senator for Arizona John Kyl - on April 8th - flat out lied about how many abortions planned parenthood carries out in the official records it will say 90% in a later statement from the senators office he said 3% but that isn't what goes on record.  To their credit lots of people have called him on it - including John Stewart on the Daily Show - faux news has more integrity than FOX news.  That's just one example I'm sure there are many more, so here's what I want to know.

In order to discourage this culture of twisting the facts to suit your political agenda (yes the D's do it too but not to the same extent as the GOP and the TP) why not hook them up to a polygraph while they're on the floor - if they're caught lying they can't vote on anything that day.  And if you flip/flop you have to explain why you've decided to do a complete 180 on something you were so passionate about in state government (anyone? Romney?)

There are still some honest politicians out there but they are a dying breed.  What was once considered an honourable profession and a chance to serve the public has morphed into smoke and mirrors and money.  So when a politician or a pundit speaks by all means listen but try and discriminate fact from fiction and never stop asking questions.




http://www.freep.com/article/20110419/OPINION05/104190318/Leonard-Pitts-Jr-Political-lies-hit-new-low